
Look, I know I'm way in the minority here, but I found HBO's latest triumph lacking a bit of oomph. I know, I know – critics are hailing it as the greatest thing since The Sopranos. And the pilot was a rare opportunity to see Martin Scorsese work in TV.
I just wish I gave a damn.
To its credit, Boardwalk Empire is terrifically well put together. The combo of extensive sets and CGI extensions that re-create Atlantic City in the 20s are absolutely beautiful. The cast is first-rate. It's sumptuously shot and richly staged. And so on. But for me, it never really added up to anything past an expensive exercise in putting on a period piece.
It's Mad Men Syndrome again – a series of artfully arranged set pieces and lingering glances that are supposed to stir your soul because the lighting's so exquisite but in reality left me completely cold. The protagonist's also part of the problem – while Steve Buscemi's built a career on scene-stealing characters chock full of quirks, here it means that the main man in almost every scene is an off-putting creep with a grating whine and deep-set dead eyes.
If you're a huge Mob guy, the exploits of real-life characters might carry the day – hey look, it's Arnold Rothstein! Hey look, it's Lucky Luciano! I'll admit I got a kick out of the introduction of an up-and-coming Al Capone – if he was the star of the show, you might have something, but at this point Boardwalk Empire feels as flat as the pier it's based on.
Pass.





